Part 1 — The Night Valentina’s Quiet Life Ended
The rain hammered against Lincoln High’s windows like bullets, each drop exploding into a thousand fragments before sliding down the glass.
Chapter 1
Part 1 — The Night Valentina’s Quiet Life Ended
The rain hammered against Lincoln High’s windows like bullets, each drop exploding into a thousand fragments before sliding down the glass.
I should have left hours ago, but the stack of ungraded art projects on my desk seemed to mock me every time I glanced at the clock. I was 26 years old, spending another Friday night alone in an empty school building, surrounded by watercolor disasters and charcoal smudges that barely resembled the Renaissance masterpieces I had assigned.
The fluorescent lights above flickered sporadically, casting eerie shadows across the classroom walls, where my students’ work hung in neat rows. Monet’s lilies reimagined by hormonal teenagers. Picasso’s cubism filtered through the lens of social media addiction. At least they had tried, which was more than I could say for the school board’s effort to keep the place funded.
I gathered the last of the projects and shoved them into my worn leather bag. The sound echoed unnaturally in the silence. Empty schools had a particular kind of quietness that seemed to
press against your eardrums, making every small noise feel amplified and somehow threatening. My heels clicked against the polished linoleum as I made my way toward the exit, past rows of battered lockers and bulletin boards announcing homecoming dates that had already passed.
The main hallway stretched before me like a tunnel, lit only by emergency lights that cast everything in an amber glow. I was fumbling with my keys at the front door when I heard it.
A sharp crack, like a branch snapping.
Then another.
And another.
Gunshots.
My blood turned to ice.
The sounds were coming from the parking lot, muffled by the storm but unmistakable. I pressed myself against the wall beside the door, my heart hammering so hard I was certain it would give me away to whatever was happening outside. Through the narrow window, I could see the shadows of several figures moving between
the cars. The rain made everything blurry, but I could make out the outlines of expensive vehicles, sleek and dark like predators waiting in the night.
Another shot.
A body fell.
I bit down on my knuckle to keep from crying out, tasting blood. This could not be happening. Not there. Not at my school. Not on a random Friday night when I should have been home grading papers and eating leftover Chinese food.
The figures moved with purpose now, dragging something heavy toward 1 of the cars. I caught a glimpse of a face in the brief illumination of a cell phone screen: sharp cheekbones, cold eyes, an expression of complete indifference as he wiped his hands on what looked like an expensive handkerchief.
I needed to run. Every instinct screamed at me to get away, to find somewhere safe, to call the police. But my legs felt like
they were made of concrete, and my hands shook so violently that I dropped my keys.
They hit the floor with a metallic clatter that seemed to echo through the entire building.
The sound stopped everything.
The figures outside went still, and I watched in horror as that same face turned toward the school building. Even through the rain and darkness, I could feel his gaze searching, hunting.
I could not breathe. I could not move. I could not think beyond the single terrifying realization that I had just witnessed a murder.
And now the killer knew someone was watching.
My phone.
I needed to call 911. Needed to get help. Needed to do something other than stand there like a deer caught in headlights. But when I reached for it, my purse slipped from my shoulder, its contents spilling across the floor with a sound like thunder in the silence.
That was when I heard the footsteps.
Slow. Deliberate. Moving closer to the building.
I ran.
My heels slipped on the polished floor as I sprinted down the hallway, past the empty classrooms and darkened offices. I needed somewhere to hide. Somewhere they could not find me.
The bathroom.
The women’s bathroom at the far end of the building. It had a lock. Maybe they would not think to look there.
I burst through the door and immediately turned the deadbolt, pressing my back against the cold metal as I tried to catch my breath. The bathroom was small, with just 3 stalls and a row of sinks beneath a cracked mirror. Harsh fluorescent lighting made everything look sickly and pale.
I could hear them now, moving through the building, doors opening and closing, footsteps echoing off the walls. They were searching methodically, room by room.
I slipped into the last stall and locked it behind me, climbing onto the toilet seat so my feet would not be visible. My phone showed no signal. Of course. The school was old, built like a fortress, and cell service had always been spotty.
The bathroom door handle turned.
My heart stopped.
The deadbolt would hold. It had to.
I pressed my hand over my mouth to muffle my breathing, listening as someone tested the door more forcefully.
Then silence.
I waited, counting the seconds, praying they had moved on.
One minute.
Two.
Three.
The lights went out.
In the absolute darkness, I heard the soft click of the lock being picked. Professional. Efficient. Terrifying.
The door opened with barely a whisper of sound.
“I know you’re here.”
The voice was low and controlled, with the faintest trace of an accent I could not place. Italian, maybe.
“You saw something you shouldn’t have seen.”
I held my breath, pressing myself against the stall wall as if I could somehow disappear into it.
“I’m not going to hurt you,” he continued, his footsteps moving slowly across the tile floor. “But we need to talk about what you witnessed. About what happens now.”
He was close. So close I could hear the soft rustle of expensive fabric as he moved.
“You can come out now, or I can come find you. Your choice.”
The silence stretched between us like razor wire. I could feel his presence in the darkness, patient and immovable. This was not someone who made idle threats.
Slowly, on trembling legs, I unlocked the stall door and stepped out into the black void of the bathroom.
A beam of light hit my face, blinding me momentarily. When my eyes adjusted, I found myself staring at a man who looked as if he had stepped out of a Renaissance painting. Dark hair, perfectly styled despite the rain. Sharp features carved from marble. Eyes the color of winter ice, seeming to see straight through me.
He was beautiful in the way dangerous things often are: deadly, compelling, and absolutely terrifying.
“Valentina Costa,” he said.
My blood turned to ice water.
He knew my name.
“Twenty-six years old. Art teacher. Lives alone in apartment 3B on Maple Street. Parents died in a car accident 8 years ago. Left you with $30,000 in debt that you’re still paying off.”
“How do you—”
“I make it my business to know these things.”
He stepped closer, and I caught the scent of expensive cologne mixed with something metallic.
Blood.
“The question is, Miss Costa, what am I going to do with you now?”
Continue reading